Beyond Canon
RSS


Penname: Winterwitch [Contact] Real name:
Member Since: June 01 2014
Membership status: Member
Bio:

Gender: male
Tumblr: Winterwitch
[Report This]
Reviews by Winterwitch
Wild and Untamed Thing by Zhie Rated: General Fiction [Reviews - 2]
Summary: The oncoming war brings changes, some great and some small, in Imladris; inspired by O. Henry's "Gift of the Magi".
Categories: Stories of Arda > Bunniverse (PPB-AU) > Second Age
Characters: Asfaloth, Elrond, Erestor, Glorfindel, Thranduil
Awards: None
Challenge: None
Genre: Dramatic, Historical, Mystery
Special Collection: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 2494 Read Count: 3544
[Report This] Published: July 26 2007 Updated: July 26 2007
Reviewer: Winterwitch Signed
Date: July 17 2014 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

What a deligthful tale from this period! I like how you show life at Imladris at this early time, and Elrond's imperfections as its leaders – his growing as such as well as the growing of the settlement truly fascinate me. This herd of Glorfindel's and Asfaloth's role in it – such a terrific idea. The hair question surprised me at first, as i had never heard bows to be strung with hair. But of course, it would be difficult to find sufficient hair at short notice, and your take on it is very plausible. Do you happen to know how the hair was used to string bows? Was it plaited, or used in strands like horse-hair on a violin bow? I've only ever shot a medieval bow twice and can remember how strong the pull is, and imagine it must me much more difficult to use hair than tendons to string a bow well. But poor, dear Erestor! What a valiant and thoughtful gesture.

Reawakening by Zhie Rated: General Fiction [Reviews - 2]
Summary: The return of the great Balrog slayer of Gondolin.
Categories: Stories of Arda > Bunniverse (PPB-AU) > Second Age
Characters: Asfaloth, Glorfindel, Namo, Orome
Awards: None
Challenge: None
Genre: Comedic, Historical
Special Collection: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 1127 Read Count: 3170
[Report This] Published: September 06 2007 Updated: September 06 2007
Reviewer: Winterwitch Signed
Date: June 01 2014 Title: Chapter 1: Complete Story

I like your take on Glorfindel's rebirth, and parituclarly your explanation for Asfaloth's spresence and immortality! :O)

Elves, From A to Z by Zhie Rated: General Fiction [Reviews - 1]
Summary: Glorfindel feels left out, and Erestor tries to find ways for him to feel more included after his rebirth. Notes: (Dedicated to Maggie, for Valarda, the original ‘valley’ girl ^_^. Happy Birthday, Oro!) 2250, Second Age; PPB Universe friendly; Written from the JFA challenge list – ‘Elves, from A to Z’.
Categories: Stories of Arda > Bunniverse (PPB-AU) > Second Age
Characters: Aredhel, Beleg, Erestor, Glorfindel, Valarda
Awards: None
Challenge: JFA Challenge
Genre: Dramatic, Historical
Special Collection: Elfling Chronicles
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 2106 Read Count: 2634
[Report This] Published: September 08 2007 Updated: September 08 2007
Reviewer: Winterwitch Signed
Date: June 01 2014 Title: Chapter 1: Complete

What a sweet story! ♥ Poor Glorfindel must really feel exposed to be acknowledged in this way, and then to find out why... *g* But how good of Erestor to change that, and write that second edition for his friend.

Nenya by Zhie Rated: General Fiction [Reviews - 2]
Summary: Celeborn's reaction to Nenya.
Categories: Stories of Arda > Bunniverse (PPB-AU) > Second Age
Characters: Celeborn, Galadriel
Awards: None
Challenge: None
Genre: Dramatic
Special Collection: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 1870 Read Count: 2784
[Report This] Published: February 10 2008 Updated: February 10 2008
Reviewer: Winterwitch Signed
Date: June 01 2014 Title: Chapter 1: Complete

I love to see them as a perfectly normal couple. And I wonder what Galadriel will have to say to the same question many years later... *g*

Midsummer Memories by Zhie Rated: General Fiction [Reviews - 1]
Summary: Glorfindel spends his first midsummer after his rebirth in Lindon. Second age. Glorfindel, Erestor, Elrond, Gil-Galad, and three semi-persistent ellyth.
Categories: Stories of Arda > Bunniverse (PPB-AU) > Second Age
Characters: Elrond, Erestor, Gil-Galad, Glorfindel
Awards: None
Challenge: None
Genre: Comedic, Dramatic
Special Collection: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 2709 Read Count: 3128
[Report This] Published: July 15 2008 Updated: July 15 2008
Reviewer: Winterwitch Signed
Date: June 01 2014 Title: Chapter 1: Complete

Elrond dancing with swords? My, that is an image I would have liked to see with my own eyes! *ggg* Poor Glorfindel, though, it must be hard to in this situation. I't lovely to see he got something out of this festival eventually, and that he could share a bit of his past with Gil-galad.

I Say I Say I Say by Zhie Rated: General Fiction [Reviews - 1]
Summary: Erestor still grieves for the loss of his friends in Gondolin, but comes to find peace and hope in Greenwood and later, in the newly founded Imladris.
Categories: Stories of Arda > Bunniverse (PPB-AU) > Second Age
Characters: Elrond, Erestor, Ilmendin, Irmo, Namo, Nienna, Oropher, Thaladir, Thranduil
Awards: None
Challenge: None
Genre: Dramatic, Historical, Spiritual
Special Collection: None
Series: None
Chapters: 2 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 1604 Read Count: 12033
[Report This] Published: October 20 2008 Updated: October 20 2008
Reviewer: Winterwitch Signed
Date: June 01 2014 Title: Chapter 1: Introduction

A lovely vignette! Seeing Erestor as Oropher's foster son is delightful - he has earned some comfort after all!